08600: psu [khamrai]: This game's copy is definitely not from ReDump set.

ID	Category [?]	Severity [?]	Reproducibility	Date Submitted	Last Update
08600	Media Support	Feature	Always	Apr 9, 2023, 10:46	Apr 15, 2023, 23:14

Tester	VasiliyFamiliya	View Status	Public	Platform	MAME (Official Binary)
Assigned To		Resolution	Open	OS	Windows 10/11 (64-bit)
Status [?]	Acknowledged			Driver	sony/psx.cpp
Version	0.253	Fixed in Version		Build	64-bit
		Fixed in Git Commit		Github Pull Request #

Summary	08600: psu [khamrai]: This game's copy is definitely not from ReDump set.
Description	Its origin is questionable, because, as it shown by the test through ePSXe, it has an intro of some Taiwanese release group (http://web.archive.org/web/20010701000000*/shpwlw.yeah.net ).
Steps To Reproduce	DeCHD the game image using extractcd command, and launch it through the ePSXe (Mednafen and BizHawk perceives the taken images as a broken). Please pay an attention that intro FOLLOWS the "Produced by Namco" logo, NOT APPEARS BEFORE it. To enter the game by itself, try to press the Start button BEFORE intro stop to flicker, otherwise the game will freeze.
Additional Information	Any attempts to take a snapshot or record an intro appearance on a video were failed.
Github Commit

Flags
Regression Version
Affected Sets / Systems	psu [khamrai]

Attached Files

No.21318 Robbbert Senior Tester Apr 15, 2023, 11:44	I don't see the point of this report. There's nothing in the softlist entry that mentions Redump, so I am not at all sure what you're talking about, or what you want to be done.
No.21322 Balthier Tester Apr 15, 2023, 16:50 edited on: Apr 16, 2023, 10:00	Maybe read what he said again. He very clearly states that the dump of the game in mame softlist is not a Redump verified dump but rather a "scene release" that has an intro hacked in, made by a release group, it's why "No-Intro" site came to being. <Edited for content - don't do this again> Anyway, grabbed a copy myself to check, and yeah mame has a dirty copy (no surprise as a lot of the software stuff needs to be cleaned up). Relevant psx.xml info states: <!-- Hangs at Sony logo --> <software name="khamrai" supported="no"> <!-- Unknown source <rom name="Khamrai (Japan) [SLPS-02640].bin" size="497927808" crc="038d3517" sha1="402b483eed87523a10f7e5b19e06e17f8e6e479b"/> <rom name="Khamrai (Japan) [SLPS-02640].cue" size="92" crc="a188ad90" sha1="20b930616d16c3aa07dedcf2b735bf26926b5658"/> --> <description>Khamrai (Japan)</description> <year>2000</year> <publisher>Namco</publisher> <info name="serial" value="SLPS-02640" /> <info name="release" value="20001005" /> <info name="alt_title" value="カムライー神来ー"/> <sharedfeat name="compatibility" value="NTSC-J"/> <part name="cdrom" interface="psx_cdrom"> <diskarea name="cdrom"> <disk name="khamrai (japan) [slps-02640]" sha1="05c1e4d59668a34d35b643e5d117619a8430242e" status="baddump"/> </diskarea> </part> </software> And redump info http://redump.org/disc/19575/ says: 1 Data/Mode 2 00:00:00 47:02:54 211704 497927808 c540e386 82e83717581cfd3be10daee0a816e3d4 c5d1fefdfd8311c7bcfb5e53e99b6040a561fb8a Only one dumper so not a green verification but fuzzball has been dumping for years so I trust his dumps. Edit: tried out the official dump from redump and it works beautifully other than the fat top and right black borders during the opening movie in screenshots. When did PlayStation emulation get so good in mame? Lol. https://i.imgur.com/rW4UWYM.png https://i.imgur.com/njmOAzB.png https://i.imgur.com/bDkgwxd.png That was running with "psj" bios and not "psu". @VasiliyFamiliya why did you try to run the game using the "psu" bios? You do realize that's American and not the proper Japanese bios? Not good to attempt to run a game using the wrong region bios.
No.21323 Tafoid Administrator Apr 15, 2023, 23:14	Acknowledged for checking later