| ID | Category [?] | Severity [?] | Reproducibility | Date Submitted | Last Update |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 09495 | Misc. | Minor | Always | 19 days ago | 18 days ago |
| Tester | joemagiera | View Status | Public | Platform | MAME (Official Binary) |
| Assigned To | Resolution | Invalid report | OS | Windows (x64) | |
| Status [?] | Closed | Driver | |||
| Version | 0.286 | Fixed in Version | Build | x64 | |
| Fixed in Git Commit | Github Pull Request # | ||||
| Summary | 09495: MAME core ROMIdent: MAME -romident needs update | ||||
| Description |
Missile Command has an aftermarket revision Super Missile Attack (made by General Computer Corporation). Part of the conversion is to move the Missile Command revision 2 ROMs to the Super Missile Attack board. The only ROM image difference between Missile Command revision 2 and revision 3 is the ROM located at KL1: revision 2: 035822-02.kl1 revision 3: 035822-03e.kl1 General Computer Corporation addresses the -03e version in their documentation (I have attached it here, see question 4 at the bottom of the page) specifically stating the -03e version is also supported. I have tested the -03e version on real hardware and it works fine. See the attached report, which is a MAME -romident on these two ROMs. 035822-02,kl1 is properly identified as being in Missile Command rev 2 and Super Missile Attack (rev 1). However, 035822-03e.kl1 is only identified as being part of Missile Command rev 3 and is not identified as being valid in Super Missile Attack. |
||||
| Steps To Reproduce |
Put these two ROM images (from Missile Command rev 2 & rev 3 ROMsets): revision 2: 035822-02.kl1 revision 3: 035822-03e.kl1 into a folder within your main MAME directory (I'll call this folder MC-SMA for this example). Go into DOS command mode and be in the main MAME directory. Enter this command: MAME -romident MC-SMA >MCSMA.txt Open newly created file, MCSMA.txt (will be in your MAME directory). Review results. |
||||
| Additional Information |
All that's needed is for MAME -ROMIDENT is to recognize/report that the -03e ROM is also part of Super Missile Attack (rev 1). This might necessitate creating a second Super Missile Attack ROMset. However, there is a "not encrypted" version of Super Missile Attack (MAME ROMset name suprmatkd). Each of the original revision 2 ROMs are hacked to support a not encrypted version of Super Missile Attack. There may be a need to create/support a not encrypted -03e ROM for the Super Missile Attack (not encrypted). |
||||
| Github Commit | |||||
| Flags | |||||
| Regression Version | |||||
| Affected Sets / Systems | MAME core ROMIdent | ||||
|
Attached Files
|
| ||||
| [Show Content] | |||||
 No.24464
Robbbert Moderator
19 days ago
|
C:\MAME>mame suprmatk -lr ROMs required for driver "suprmatk". Name Size Checksum 035820-02.c1 2048 CRC(7a62ce6a) SHA1(9a39978138dc28fdefe193bfae1b226391e471db) 035821-02.b1 2048 CRC(df3bd57f) SHA1(0916925d3c94d766d33f0e4badf6b0add835d748) 035822-02.a1 2048 CRC(a1cd384a) SHA1(a1dd0953423750a0fbc6e3dccbf2ca64ef5a1f54) 035823-02.a5 2048 CRC(82e552bb) SHA1(d0f22894f779c74ceef644c9f03d840d9545efea) 035824-02.b5 2048 CRC(606e42e0) SHA1(9718f84a73c66b4e8ef7805a7ab638a7380624e1) 035825-02.c5 2048 CRC(f752eaeb) SHA1(0339a6ce6744d2091cc7e07675e509b202b0f380) e0.d5 2048 CRC(d0b20179) SHA1(e2a9855899b6ff96b8dba169e0ab83f00a95919f) e1.e5 2048 CRC(c6c818a3) SHA1(b9c92a85c07dd343d990e196d37b92d92a85a5e0) 035826-01.l6 32 CRC(86a22140) SHA1(2beebf7855e29849ada1823eae031fc98220bc43) 63s141.b2 256 CRC(2de8ee4d) SHA1(ff28c007df9c52227dfce76af6f7b1dfac3c2296) 63s141.b4 256 CRC(390fc532) SHA1(f9adde3f18f3db225ac3f3771c38ff139ef0a65e) C:\MAME>mame missile -lr ROMs required for driver "missile". Name Size Checksum 035820-02.h1 2048 CRC(7a62ce6a) SHA1(9a39978138dc28fdefe193bfae1b226391e471db) 035821-02.jk1 2048 CRC(df3bd57f) SHA1(0916925d3c94d766d33f0e4badf6b0add835d748) 035822-03e.kl1 2048 CRC(1a2f599a) SHA1(2deb1219223032a9c83114e4e8b2fc11a570754c) 035823-02.lm1 2048 CRC(82e552bb) SHA1(d0f22894f779c74ceef644c9f03d840d9545efea) 035824-02.np1 2048 CRC(606e42e0) SHA1(9718f84a73c66b4e8ef7805a7ab638a7380624e1) 035825-02.r1 2048 CRC(f752eaeb) SHA1(0339a6ce6744d2091cc7e07675e509b202b0f380) 035826-01.l6 32 CRC(86a22140) SHA1(2beebf7855e29849ada1823eae031fc98220bc43) You appear to be in error. Rom 035822-03e.kl1 CRC(1a2f599a) is only used in "missile" - not in any other set. |
|---|---|
 No.24469
cuavas Administrator
18 days ago
|
The premise of the report, that -romident is a thing on its own that can somehow be "updated", it's completely flawed. You need at least a basic understanding of MAME to report issues. |